IoD welcomes Milburn Review's focus on supporting employers to hire young people

Responding to the publication of the Milburn Review, ‘From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation’, Alex Hall-Chen, Principal Policy Advisor for Employment at the Institute of Directors, said:

“The Institute of Directors welcomes the ambition of this report to tackle the UK’s growing challenge of economic inactivity among young people and improve pathways into employment, training and education. The scale of youth disengagement from the labour market represents both a social challenge and an economic one, at a time when many businesses continue to struggle with skills shortages.

“We particularly welcome the report’s recognition that employers are central to the solution. Business is a force for good in our society, creating jobs, providing training opportunities, and helping young people gain the practical experience needed to build successful careers. The emphasis on strengthening technical education and improving transitions between education and work is therefore encouraging.

“The report is also right to acknowledge that policy decisions can have unintended consequences for youth employment. The feedback from employers is clear: the cumulative impact of the Employment Rights Act, double-digit minimum wage hikes, and National Insurance changes has made hiring staff, particularly young people, riskier and costlier.

“The recommendation for a Youth Opportunity Test reflects a principle the IoD has long advocated: that governments should fully consider how tax, regulatory and employment reforms affect employers’ willingness and ability to hire. Any such test will need to be accompanied by a clear commitment to act on its findings. If evidence shows that particular policies are reducing opportunities for young people, government must be prepared to revisit and amend them.

“While the report is right to recognise that some recent employment reforms, such as the right to guaranteed hours, risk reducing job opportunities for young people, these concerns are not limited to a single measure. Employers are also reporting that changes to unfair dismissal rules, including the introduction of additional protections after six months’ service, are making them more cautious about taking a chance on unproven candidates, with younger workers likely to be among the hardest hit.

“To seriously address the demand side issues identified in the report, the principle underlying the Youth Opportunity Test needs to be applied to the full labour market environment which they experience, including the entire programme of employment law and tax changes which have been implemented over the past two years.

“While additional hiring incentives would be welcome, they are unlikely on their own to deliver the step change in employer behaviour needed to tackle youth inactivity. IoD research finds that only one in five employers said such incentives would make them more likely to recruit young people in the coming year. Addressing the factors that have made employers more cautious about hiring in the first place would have a much greater impact. In that context, the report’s proposal to reduce employer National Insurance contributions for 21 to 24-year-olds is a particularly welcome recommendation.

“The report’s emphasis on the critical role that the education and skills system, particularly apprenticeships, plays in preparing young people to be work-ready will resonate with employers. However, the government should avoid treating the apprenticeship system as a zero-sum game by restricting older workers’ access to apprenticeships. Its first priority should be to allocate the full Growth and Skills Levy take to the apprenticeship budget, so that all funds raised from employers are allocated to upskilling and reskilling workers across the economy.

“The IoD looks forward to working with government and business leaders to ensure that more young people can access meaningful employment opportunities while supporting the competitiveness and growth of UK businesses.”

Alongside its response to the Milburn Review, the Institute of Directors is today publishing a short research paper which looks at the how employers view the interaction between various tenets of government employment policy, including minimum wage increases and the Employment Rights Act, and the rise in youth unemployment.

The Institute also recently published its report, ‘Business. A Force for Good?’, which is the culmination of an independent Commission chaired by Lord Rees of Easton OBE.

Better directors for a better world

The IoD supports directors and business leaders across the UK and beyond to learn, network and build successful, responsible businesses.
Internet Explorer
Your web browser is out of date and is not supported by the IoD website. It is important to update your browser for increased security and a better web experience.