Director Magazine

The Milburn Review was right to put a spotlight on the role of employers in creating work for young people. But will ministers listen?

This week’s Milburn Review set out an ambitious vision for a fundamental shift in how the government tackles economic inactivity among young people: ‘From a welfare state to a working state’, as its title puts it. 

With nearly a million young people currently not in employment, education or training (NEET), that ambition is much to be welcomed.

So, too, is a critical aspect of the Review that has been rather lost in discussions over recent days.

Milburn highlights the need for action on the demand side of the employment equation – that is, to encourage employers to hire more young people. He wants employers to create more first jobs, to make more first jobs apprenticeships, and to open up work experience.

Yet he also acknowledges what we have long been saying: that policy choices made in recent years have deterred employers from taking on young people.

As we have repeatedly explained to policymakers, hiring decisions are all about risk – and the reality is that hiring a young person without work experience is inherently riskier. When employers assess candidates who don’t yet have a track record in work, they have relatively little data about that person’s suitability for the job.

Employers could offset those risks against lower costs. But over the past two years, employment reforms have changed that equation. The Employment Rights Act (ERA) is making it harder to dismiss employees who might prove to be unsuited to the job. And costs have been pushed up dramatically. The headline National Living Wage (NMW) rose 37% between 2020 and 2026 while the minimum wage rate for 18-year-olds increased 51%. On top of that, employers have had to factor in higher National Insurance Contributions (NICs) for over 21s.

The policies of the past two years did not create the NEET crisis, but they have exacerbated it.

An effective policy response means tackling these fundamentals rather than launching another youth employment scheme. Such schemes are ultimately sticking plasters, with limited impact on employer decision-making. IoD research in April 2026 found that only 20% of employers reported being more likely to hire young people as a result of the youth employment incentives announced in March this year. Getting more employers to create opportunities for young people will require action focused on the core risks and costs associated with hiring them.

These three steps would be a good start.

1. Reduce NICs for young people.

Milburn proposes NICs relief for 21–24-year-olds, which could have an immediate impact on employers’ willingness to hire. The Prime Minister says that the idea will be considered “very carefully”, but the FT has already reported Treasury sources pushing back. If the government is serious about encouraging employers to hire young people, this should not be ruled out.

2. Rethink the Employment Rights Act, starting with zero hours rules.

We have long warned that the ERA will dampen hiring intentions. The ongoing consultations on its implementation create opportunities to listen to employers’ concerns, starting with planned changes on zero hours contracts. The government favours a 12-week reference period; we have called for this to be one year so that the guaranteed hours reflect seasonal variations in demand. This would be hugely welcomed by employers – and it has the attraction of not costing the Treasury a penny.

3. Extend the pause on National Minimum Wage increases for young people.

As the policy of equalising NMW levels for young people has kicked in, employers have asked, “Why should I take a risk on an unproven 18-year-old, when for just a little more I could hire somebody with proven experience?” Extending the pause on increases for 18–20-year-olds won’t undo the damage already done, but would at least avoid making the situation worse.

Milburn’s comprehensive review could drive major reforms across welfare, education and training in the years ahead. Yet if the government is to succeed in tackling the NEET crisis, it will also have to listen to Milburn on the need to rebalance the risk equation around employing young people. We hope ministers will seize this opportunity.

About the author

image of Alex Hall-Chen

Alex Hall-Chen

Principal Policy Advisor for Sustainability, Employment, and Skills at the IoD

Alex Hall-Chen is Principal Policy Advisor for Sustainability, Employment, and Skills at the IoD. She previously worked in education research and as a Policy Advisor at the CBI. She holds a BA in Politics and Sociology from the University of Cambridge and an MSc in Comparative and International Education from the University of Oxford, and is a school governor for the Thinking Schools Academy Trust.

Get updates from Director

The latest news and advice on issues that matter to business leaders, straight to your in-box.

There has been an unexpected error.

Thank you for subscribing.

Unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy.

Internet Explorer
Your web browser is out of date and is not supported by the IoD website. It is important to update your browser for increased security and a better web experience.