Skip to main content
Become a member
  • Register
  • Login

Register Login


Government immigration policy still needs work before it can help UK to compete on global stage

18 Dec 2018

peopleResponding to the publication of the Government’s White Paper, The UK’s Future Skills-based Immigration System, Stephen Martin, Director General of the Institute of Directors, said:

“The White Paper gives with one hand and takes away with the other. There are some useful proposals, such as removing the cap for high skilled visas and lowering the qualifications requirement to A-level or advanced apprenticeship, but the £30,000 salary threshold is still in there for consultation, which could affect around 60% of jobs at intermediate skills levels. We urge Ministers to listen to business and step back from this threshold. Fundamentally, it still seems that the Government’s immigration policy is being driven by the unattainable, distracting and economically illogical net migration target. Measures such as the new 12-month temporary visas do not change this.

“Context is everything here. Unemployment is near record lows, vacancies are at all-time highs and businesses are reporting skills shortages at all levels. There is both an absolute shortage of people available, which can’t be met by the domestic workforce, and specific gaps in  areas that companies need to keep up with global competition. This is shown clearly in the fact that as EU migration has slowed, non-EU migration has risen to fill the need. Politicians cannot ignore the facts. The White Paper admits that the predicted fall in workers from Europe will cost the Exchequer up to £4 billion over the first five years.

“The Government’s own Migration Advisory Committee has found that migrants boost innovation and do not reduce training of UK workers. This is consistent with everything our members tell us – they simply want to find the right people to make their businesses better. The economy faces many challenges, both in the short and the long term, and none of them will be easier to address if we pull up the drawbridge. Trying to compete in an increasingly fractious global economy with an overly restrictive migration policy is like trying to run a marathon with your shoelaces tied together.”

Picture of the 2018 Professional Development Portfolio

You decide how high you reach and how far you go with the IoD. Download your autumn/winter training calendar now.

Download here

Contact IoD Scotland 

For more information, please contact

0131 557 5488


Branch and staff contacts can be found on the main Contacts tab

IoD Scotland
10 Charlotte Square

Charlotte Square is a garden square in Edinburgh, Scotland, part of the New Town, designated a UNESCO World Heritage Site. The square is located at the west end of George Street and was intended to mirror St. Andrew Square in the east. The gardens are private and not publicly accessible.